my teacher read this book to me in 5th grade and it was a little sad but very interesting :)

I like this book so far. I Think Erin Hunter is a good writer, very creative.

I like this book it's funny and I like the end of it, the author keeps you reading.

I love this book series! this is book two in the series it's very good and keeps you on the edge of your seat.

I love this book series! This is probably my favorite book in the series so far.

I love this book series! This book is very good would defiantly recommend this series to anyone!

I Love this book series. this is a very good book in the series book five.

I Love this book series. I love this book so far its very good!

I want to read this!

I haven't read this book yet. I'm on the second chapter its a good book so far.