I just love this book. Im glad Mai Nyugen decided to take her in. They are so nice. I felt deeply moved when I read this. It is just really good.

I just love this!!! This just perfectly describes the feelings of a girl plunged into a new world!! I already read the whole series and it is - hands down - the best book I have ever read! ( And that's saying a lot, since I basically read one book every day.) I hope Shannon makes some more like this!!!!

I love this book! I really enjoyed it because it has dragons. Also, I really like clay because he is so nice - and a big eater- like me!!!! I can't wait to read the third book! ( I already read the second one :)

I really loved this book. It is dangerous and dark, but the good shines through it like moonlight beam. Tigerstar is training the Dark Forest warriors- and the Clan cats, to be traitor, even if they don't know it. Ivypool was one of them, until she realized that Tigerstar was as false and murderous as he was in real life. This book is really sad too, Starclan comes to help fight, but some die another death. One special cat dies, and isn't able to meet Firestar. Also, a great Clan cat dies (it was very unexpected), but he joins Starclan as youthful and strong as before. I really liked this book. I hope you all can read it!