It's SO GOOD. I almost cried when Sandstorm died. It's very good, but the first, 2nd, and 4th are the best series. Can't wait for the next one!

It's good, but not the BEST book Margret has ever written. I think the best would be Under Their Skin of Shadow Children. But still, it's REALLY GOOD. Haddix is one of the best authors EVER.

So good. Bramblestar, leader of Thunderclan, is struggling. Every descion he makes he asks himself, "Is this what Firestar would do?" But then, a huge storm hits, and they are forced to leave their home. He takes in kittypets and help Shadowclan, and soon realizes that he's not Firestar. SO GOOD!!

At first when I was in, 3rd grade, everyone was reading these books, and I wasn't impressed. I'd tried to read it, and the words were just bland. But then, in 4th grade, my mom, me, and my sister started it. I was amazed. I wanted to read more and more. This book is awesome. Amazing. Incredible.

This book is so sad, yet so amazing. It almost made me cry, and I don't cry over books often. "Horses lie dead and dying everywhere"? But friendship really helps, with Topthorn and Albert, Joey finally learns what it means to never give up. So amazing, I love Michael Morpurgo's work. So great. I've read this book about.... hmm, 20 times, and yet I never get bored.